Let me see if I can address some of the issues you brought up.

Originally Posted by
mr shickadance
..with a pipe, as long as it fits, and is made out of the proper material there really is not much to it...
fundamentally, this is not incorrect. However, while a basic test pipe doesn't require much, it is slightly more complex than "just a pipe with a bend". Keep in mind you need the proper flanges and bungs, as well as good solid welds. let's not forget about the conditions this pipe routinely encounters, from heat cycles to engine vibrations. Sure you could throw that ebay pipe on there, but do you trust that it will never fail? and what if it does? which brings me to my next point.

Originally Posted by
mr shickadance
warranties for this specific product do not really make it or break it for me, because you are going to know within the first 30 days whether or not that pipe is going to fit or not and ebay and paypal offer buyer protection. but in terms of the product failing, if its made out of the right material and installed correctly it will never fail (again we are talking about a pipe with a bend in it)
You will know as soon as you go to install a test pipe if it fits or not. The Ebay and Paypal protections offer a bit of peace of mind, but when it comes down to it they don't offer the protection you receive from a company's warranty. Under normal circumstances, sure failure rates are low. But what happens if, unknown to anyone, an exhaust hanger pops loose and the exhaust shakes a bit more than it's supposed to, an engine mount goes out and the exhaust gets tweaked, or an exhasut shop does a custom cat back and it doesn't fit perfectly, all these could potentially cause a weld to break and the Test Pipe to fail. Who covers that then?

Originally Posted by
mr shickadance
the spacer a lot of people will tell you is hit or miss and going stage 2 with most softwares will rid your car of the CEL and to be honest i bought the spacer when i bought my TP and never even installed the sucker cause i found out that if i paid 50 bucks i could get flashed to uni stage 2 and it would garuntee i would not get the cel so i opted for that.
sure, some people may not get a CEL for whatever reason. But for those that do throw a code (and it's pretty safe to assume this is most) our o2 spacer has interchangeable jets to allow for further tuning of the o2 bung. This insures there will be no CEL. The spacer is included at no additional cost, so there is nothing to buy separately, and no cost to upgrade your software.

Originally Posted by
mr shickadance
there are more then a few az members who have the ebay tp and other then an occasional fitment issue have no problems with the performance of the part
As I mentioned in my personal post above, I was one of those members who had an ebay TP. Fitment was fine, but it was slightly too short, and over time caused my flex pipe to tear. Was the performance affected? No. Did improper fitment cause damage to other components? yes.

Originally Posted by
mr shickadance
my original point tho, is that RAI compared thier TP against a stock cat. to me this seems like a waste of time testing because i think we all know that there will be performance gains when you do that.
Yes and no. If you are starting with a stock car, these numbers are very useful. If you're looking to upgrade your ebay test pipe, I understand why you'd want to see the data. Like I said, we're going to try and swap the old TP back in to get some numbers.

Originally Posted by
mr shickadance
...hfc from O34, for another 100 dollars you dont have to deal with the downsides that come with the test pipe, significantly louder exhaust ... smelly exhaust/interior, over time darkening of the rear bumper due to the exhaust gasses...
To accurately compare 034's HFC to our TP, be sure to include the cost of hardware and o2 spacer. now your looking at almost twice the cost. Just something to think about. Also, having driven a car with a test pipe for over 20,000 miles, I can attest to the little (if any) smell and soot deposits

Originally Posted by
mr shickadance
im not saying one is better then the other im just trying to point out that without proof that RAI test pipe is any better in performance (and performance alone) then an ebay tp or hfc then spending 200 for a product that can be purchased for 70 just seems....not smart
I don't want anything I said to seem as if I was copping an attitude, and I really appreciate the honest reactions and opinions because I'm sure you are not alone. Said and done I, and everyone at RAI fully stand behind our product. at the end of the day your money gets you performance, value, and support. I guarantee you wont be disappointed.
Bookmarks