
Originally Posted by
ywang98
I could not live with the trade-off, so I got the Comp. It IS the best compromise for this car. Not too harsh, absorbs the small bumps (better than the DRC), and the large bumps, it just eats it then total control of bounces. I smile every time I drive the car and marvel at how good the suspension is.
I had an R32 that I put on some V1 KW coilovers. That was a stiff ride albeit with great control, but the Comp's suspension is so civilized when compared to that.

Originally Posted by
Dan99
I have read similar things about most of the coilover options, but the Competition Package seems to make people a lot happier than the aftermarket options. I've tried unsuccessfully to find one to drive (there are at least 10 Audi dealers in the metro area) but, so far, all of the ones in stock are spoken for and unavailable for a test drive.
I was finally able to drive an RS5 Sportback with the Competition Package (CP), and compare it back-to-back over the same roads with my B9 RS5 Sportback, which has the Sport Suspension Plus with DRC (SS+DRC).
First, I have to agree with @ywang98 that the CP is a really nice suspension. Whether or not it is the right suspension for you depends on what you want from your car.
My test drive was over a mix of high and low speed roads, smooth and rough, with some favorite turns mixed in. My overall impression is that Audi did a fantastic job with the CP. While the lowered suspension adds some challenge in our area with steep drive entrances and speed bumps, the CP is very poised, balanced and flat in turns, and the steering feels tighter and more precise without being overly heavy. It feels planted, is easy to rotate the car in turns, and it inspires more confidence. It is reminiscent of the suspensions in my previous Porsches, despite the additional weight. It's a nice option.
Since this thread is about coilovers, and not CP, it's important to remember that CP has many changes making it is hard to isolate the effect of just the coilovers when it also has track-oriented tires, different steering, different anti-roll bars and ride height, weight reduction through removal of sound insulation, changes to the transmission and Sport Differential tuning, etc. But I think I can draw enough of a contrast for those trying to decide.
Overall, my younger self would get the CP in a heartbeat; my current self is less inclined to do so despite the obvious performance enhancement. It boils down to personal preference and priorities.
The CP is "on" all of the time and it provides a level of handling that my car does not have. My car is not bad, but the CP is better. Some of that is due to the coilovers and some is due to other changes. If handling is your primary concern, and you are buying a new RS5, the CP is the obvious choice.
On the other hand, if you want a more comfortable ride in your GT car, the suspension in my car is the obvious choice. I drove the CP over the test route first. When I switched back to my car, the differences in comfort were immediately obvious. First, I did detect some bounce in Dynamic in my car over a section of road that the CP handled with no bounce. However, that bounce disappeared in Auto in my car, so blame the Dynamic damper setting, not DRC. I was left with the impression that Dynamic was over-damped for compression, not under-damped. The rear of the car would go up with each imperfection in the road, rather than absorb it. Auto absorbed these imperfections and there was no bounce.
In addition, my car in Auto felt silky smooth in Auto compared to CP. I've never thought of my suspension as silky smooth, but that was the first thing that came to mind after driving the CP over the same section of road. For example, I could feel expansion cracks in a relatively smooth concrete road with the CP, but they were non-existent with the Auto setting in my car.
As I mentioned earlier in this thread, I drove sports cars for most of my life and loved the go-kart level of handling and wanted to feel the road all of the time. Expansion cracks in concrete were not an issue for me. The CP is that type of suspension, but I eventually grew weary of feeling everything all of the time. My wife was a willing partner through all of my cars. She loved the Porsches as well and did not mind the road feel, and even spent time on the track with me, but we eventually decided that it's nice to be able to travel in a bit more comfort. My RS5 does that, but the CP does not.
If your tendency is toward sports car handling, the CP is the obvious choice. If your tendency is toward GT level of performance and comfort, I believe the Sports Suspension Plus with DRC is a better option. When my car is in Auto or Comfort it is much more comfortable yet it still corners relatively flat with DRC. So, all of this confirmed earlier discussions. CP corners flat but it is accomplished through a suspension that is more firm all of the time. DRC corners relatively flat, and does so with softer suspension settings. CP is better from a performance point of view; I prefer SS+DRC from a comfort point of view.
So, how do you translate all of this into installing third party coilovers and removing DRC? First, you will have to change more things than just the coilovers to achieve a similar outcome to CP. Tires, wheels, anti-roll bars all need to be changed, along with removing sound insulation to reduce weight, and some things can't be replicated such as steering and programming. It will also be difficult to match spring rates and damping options with third party coilovers. However, if you take a wholistic approach to the project and do more than just coilovers, it should improve handling and still corner as flat or flatter as DRC, but it will necessarily be more firm all of the time.
So, that's the trade-off. Coilovers can provide a higher level of performance and level handling over SS+DRC, in exchange for a ride that is firm all of the time.
Once again, it just depends what you want from your car. In my view, if you are looking for sharper handling in turns and don't mind a suspension that is constantly firm without being harsh, and you can live with less ground clearance, CP is the clear winner, and third party coilovers can approximate that if set up correctly. However, if you want more of a GT car and you want comfort along with performance, I think SS+DRC is the better option.
Ultimately, you should test drive them for yourself and then decide which one best fits you, but that's my take on it.
Bookmarks