Anyone cross-shop a B9 Allroad with a CPO Macan S?

[DrMikeDDS]

I swore I would never get an SUV for myself, but have read nothing but praise for the Macan.

Acceleration wise they are both similar based on Car and Driver tests.

I'm more interested in how they compare handling wise.

[onelove]

I've been doing this in my head for my next car and keep flipping the coin...... I'm a huge Porsche guy, but love my Allroad as a daily drive. The B9 is a great improvement in an already great car, especially the user interface. The Macan S handles quite nice and is real quick for an SUV, we have a BMW X5 that my wife rides and in her mind its just a step too small for her daily needs so it would have to be an Allroad replacement, have a few years to sort it out.

[KneeDragger]

Allroad & Macan S similar in acceleration??? LOL

[DrMikeDDS]

Allroad & Macan S similar in acceleration??? LOL

Car and Driver got the following results:

Allroad: 0-60: 5.2, 1/4 mile: 13.8
https://www.caranddriver.com/audi/a4-allroad-quattro

Macan: 0-60: 5.1, 1/4 mile: 13.6
https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2017-porsche-macan-s-test-review

I would say those are similar acceleration numbers.

[f_399]

Allroad 0-60 is closer to 5.7-5.9 and the 1/4 at low 14's

C&D is being generous.

Allroad is closer to a regular macan then a macan s.

[KneeDragger]

I pull bus lengths against my friends new b9 allroad in my stock 18 SQ5....they aren't even comparable vehicles.

[alhutch]

The Macan S is >500 lbs heavier w/ only 66 lb/ft more torque. That has to count against it in acceleration.

[f_399]

Pound per HP
Macan S - 12.09
SQ5 - 12.35
B8.5 APR e85 Allroad - 12.43 (just for fun)
B9 Allroad - 15.15
Macan 2.0T- 15.48

[MSq5]

A B8 supercharged 3.0T Q5 or SQ5 with a simple bolt on pulley and stage 2 tune and nothing more will run 12.7s in the quarter and 0-60 in 4.3 to 4.4 seconds on pump gas. SQ5 might be a tick or two quicker because of better OEM intercooling system.

Can't speak to B9. But these times are quicker or the same as the stock Macan Turbo, the Macan S's higher horsepower brother.

[alhutch]

Pound per HP
Macan S - 12.09
SQ5 - 12.35
B8.5 APR e85 Allroad - 12.43 (just for fun)
B9 Allroad - 15.15
Macan 2.0T- 15.48

Macan S is actually 12.9, not 12.09, so it falls down your list slightly (4388/340). Not disputing it has a better power to weight ratio, but if you compare torque, the difference isn't as clear cut.

[BrewDude]

I pull bus lengths against my friends new b9 allroad in my stock 18 SQ5....they aren't even comparable vehicles.

You've also got 102 more horsepower than the allroad. Not even a fair fight.