
Originally Posted by
jacobsen
If your alternator is putting out 14.1 volts but you're only in the twelves on your battery it sounds like your battery is bad. You might have a bad cell in your battery then you should replace it.
Absolute poppycock. The alternator must always output greater voltage than the terminal voltage of the battery to ensure there's a current flowing INTO the battery. Alternator output of 14.1V is good, battery voltage as tested @ 12.7V is good.
Terminal voltage is greater than emf whilst the battery is charging, according to (emf - V) = IR. If you substitute in appropriate numbers, you'll find a -ve value for I, current, indicating electrons flowing INTO the system. This is assuming for our purposes that -ve resistance does not exist and as we're not working with MOSFETs or electronic oscillators, I think this is a safe assumption.
The best method to find the health of a battery is to determine the internal resistance. You can do this with knowledge of Ohm's law and a good resistor. If you wanted to try this on a car battery, you'd need a well-made resistor, and a high-wattage one at that. Most resistors have a wide tolerance on resistance- this is exactly what the coloured bands on the outside denote. The last band is for tolerance on the overall resistance; there are many online resistor colour charts, but suffice it to say the tighter the tolerance the more accurate value you'll get out of the equation that follows. A purple band being acceptable comes to mind. For the Watts, use at least 10. Remember, a Watt is 1 Amp @ 1 Volt, and is a unit of power. 10-15 Watts for this method should be plenty.
V = IR, V/I = R, where V is voltage, R resistance and I current in Amps.
Using a known good voltage source like a battery charger, run your precision resistor in series with the +ve clamp and +ve terminal of the battery and simply connect the -ve clamp of charger to battery. Measure voltage across the battery terminals. Write down this value, V1.
Measure potential across the battery in the car. Record as V2. Use the following equations in order:
V1 / Ohms_Res = I
V2 / I = Ohms_Batt_Int
Ideally you want a low value that's close or less than 0.1 ohm.
Battery capacity in terms of mAh drops off with the number of charge cycles the battery has undergone, and internal resistance may not give you the whole picture because internal resistance in some cases remains a plateau throughout battery life while the capacity will decrease. Another method you could use is a DC load method. In this procedure, you measure OCV of the battery and then potential under load such as starting the car. You will require an accurate measure of amperage draw during this, and I'm apprehensive to explain that part because of the risks involved but the delta V / current = resistance.
The procedure the shop used to check your battery was likely AC conductance as they gave you a direct CCA value.
In short, your battery is fine. If people don't know wtf they're talking about they should refrain from posting "advice".
Bookmarks