Audizine - An Automotive Enthusiast Community

Results 1 to 23 of 23
  1. #1
    Veteran Member Four Rings eljay's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 13 2015
    AZ Member #
    348695
    Location
    NS

    Urgent help needed: clutch gone?

    Guest-only advertisement. Register or Log In now!
    I believe my clutch is gone, but I would like to confirm.

    Someone else was driving my car while I was a passenger just now.
    All the sudden she couldn't shift into 3rd and clutch pedal is extremely light. We pulled over.

    With car off I couldn't shift into any gear. I tried it with starting the car and same: cannot shift into any gear. Turned off engine.
    While I was looking for a towing company number, all the sudden I could shift into gears with some difficulty, but it worked. So, I started the engine with clutch pedal pressed down. The car jumped forward. I shut off the engine. I realized that gear was engaged even when the clutch pedal was pressed down.

    Since we were only a mile from my house I realized that I could just bump the car in first and get home.
    So, with first gear engaged, I started the car and gave it a bit of gas and we managed to limp home in first. Clutch pedal didn't work, so after pulling into the driveway, I just had to hit the brake and stall the car to stop it.

    Could you guys tell me what those symptoms mean?
    My clutch was on its way out (high engagement point and light pedal action). So, is this only clutch gone or do I need to replace something else? The tranny should be OK, correct? How about the clutch slave?
    Anything else?

    I'll be ordering the Valeo SMFW conversion kit asap.

    Thank you!
    Current: 2016 Audi A4 Allroad (in progress)
    Past: 2005 Audi A4 1.8T Quattro Avant / 6-speed / Ultrasport - SOLD

  2. #2
    Veteran Member Four Rings Audibot's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 20 2010
    AZ Member #
    59252
    Location
    Maryland

    Was she riding your clutch? When I was first learning I had done this a couple times, and pedal would always feel like it dropped straight to the floor. After leaving it off for sometime to cool off, it returned to normal.

  3. #3
    Veteran Member Four Rings Charles.waite's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 27 2011
    AZ Member #
    77478
    Location
    Seattle, WA

    Sounds like the pressure plate broke, or more likely the throwout lever/plate/whateveritscalled bent and isnt making contact with the pressure plate. Either that or the slave broke. How is your fluid level?
    -CP
    2008 2.0t S-Line Ti 6MT Avant
    2017 Q7 3.0t
    SOLD -- 2012 Q5 2.0t - Stock Mommy Missile with new timing chains
    Former USP CLUB MEMBER #136
    2004 A4 1.8TQ 6MT USP - APR Stage 1+ - FSI Coils - BKR7EIX-11 - B6S4 Front + B7A4 Rear Brakes - 034 Street Trans Mount
    SOLD -- 2006 A4 2.0TQ Avant Tiptronic

  4. #4
    Veteran Member Four Rings ADCS's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 06 2009
    AZ Member #
    37126
    Location
    Toronto

    Could be a fractured clutch fork/lever like Old Guy had.

    Either way you should replace it as well as the spring clip and thr other bits in there when you do the disc/PP/FW. If you look up OG's thread you will find the part numbers you need. Just make sure you get the correct fork based on your trans (5 or 6spd) since they are different. I think the one OG lists is a 5spd part number.
    B6 2.7t BEL tuned by Bische
    B7 2.0t

  5. #5
    Veteran Member Four Rings eljay's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 13 2015
    AZ Member #
    348695
    Location
    NS

    Quote Originally Posted by Charles.waite View Post
    Sounds like the pressure plate broke, or more likely the throwout lever/plate/whateveritscalled bent and isnt making contact with the pressure plate. Either that or the slave broke. How is your fluid level?
    Yes, sounds something like that. There are no rattling or odd noises. Just can't disengage gears once engaged and vice versa, randomly.
    Fluid is fine and brakes worked well. I recently bled the clutch slave too when I replaced brake fluid.
    Current: 2016 Audi A4 Allroad (in progress)
    Past: 2005 Audi A4 1.8T Quattro Avant / 6-speed / Ultrasport - SOLD

  6. #6
    Veteran Member Four Rings eljay's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 13 2015
    AZ Member #
    348695
    Location
    NS

    Quote Originally Posted by ADCS View Post
    Could be a fractured clutch fork/lever like Old Guy had.

    Either way you should replace it as well as the spring clip and thr other bits in there when you do the disc/PP/FW. If you look up OG's thread you will find the part numbers you need. Just make sure you get the correct fork based on your trans (5 or 6spd) since they are different. I think the one OG lists is a 5spd part number.
    Thanks. I'll take a look to see what else I need to order and replace while the tranny is off.
    I was hoping to have it survive winter and fiddle with it on my own on jackstands, but the more I read DIYs for clutch replacement, the more I think that it's beyond my skills and equipment to do within a few days. So, I may just have to suck this one up and pay for the service.
    Current: 2016 Audi A4 Allroad (in progress)
    Past: 2005 Audi A4 1.8T Quattro Avant / 6-speed / Ultrasport - SOLD

  7. #7
    Veteran Member Four Rings eljay's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 13 2015
    AZ Member #
    348695
    Location
    NS

    Quote Originally Posted by Audibot View Post
    Was she riding your clutch? When I was first learning I had done this a couple times, and pedal would always feel like it dropped straight to the floor. After leaving it off for sometime to cool off, it returned to normal.
    She probably was, I don't know. It only took less than a mile. The car has a GTRS kit, so that would certainly kill a dying clutch if you ride it even a little.
    Current: 2016 Audi A4 Allroad (in progress)
    Past: 2005 Audi A4 1.8T Quattro Avant / 6-speed / Ultrasport - SOLD

  8. #8
    Veteran Member Four Rings Spike00513's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 05 2013
    AZ Member #
    110766
    Location
    CA

    Quote Originally Posted by Audibot View Post
    Was she riding your clutch? When I was first learning I had done this a couple times, and pedal would always feel like it dropped straight to the floor. After leaving it off for sometime to cool off, it returned to normal.
    I was taught to only use the clutch, if I was using it.
    In other words, if I'm coasting, then keep my foot completely somewhere else off the pedal, such as on the deadpedal.

    Same for shift knob, to keep my hand off it and on the steering wheel, which the owner's manual also suggests.

    Quote Originally Posted by Charles.waite View Post
    Sounds like the pressure plate broke, or more likely the throwout lever/plate/whateveritscalled bent and isnt making contact with the pressure plate. Either that or the slave broke. How is your fluid level?
    Clutch fork. I didn't know those could break.
    Like you said, if it's the slave, I bet you'd see a leak under the car, and low fluid level.

    I think there is a tolerance spec for pressure plate fingers, which bend over time. I hear that with enough age/miles, they can actually bend too far, or even break off entirely.

    Quote Originally Posted by ADCS View Post
    Could be a fractured clutch fork/lever like Old Guy had.

    Either way you should replace it as well as the spring clip and thr other bits in there when you do the disc/PP/FW. If you look up OG's thread you will find the part numbers you need. Just make sure you get the correct fork based on your trans (5 or 6spd) since they are different. I think the one OG lists is a 5spd part number.
    Plus they're probably only a few bucks each

  9. #9
    Veteran Member Four Rings eljay's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 13 2015
    AZ Member #
    348695
    Location
    NS

    What do I need for my clutch replacement including any "while I'm there" parts? It's 2005 1.8T Quattro, 6-speed, GTRS, with 174k miles and, afaik, all original components.

    1. Valeo SMFW conversion kit - 52285615
    -- contains solid flywheel, pressure plate, clutch disc, throw-out bearing, flywheel mounting bolts, clutch alignment tool)
    2. clutch pilot bearing - 056105313C
    3. clutch fork - 01X141719B
    4. clutch release arm - 012141751C
    5. clutch release spring - 012141741
    6. ball stud - 012141777D
    7. rear main seal - 06A103171A
    8. transmission mount - 8E0399105HQ (can I just replace the rubber part? ECS seems to list both under the same part #: full and rubber-only)
    9. transmission fluid

    I got items 3-6 from old guy's recommendation in this thread.

    Anything to add to this? Any bolts to replace on the parts that will be removed?
    I found this clutch installation kit on ECS: https://www.ecstuning.com/Audi-B6_A4...Kit/ES2589667/
    Should I grab all of those components? It seems that besides my list above, it contains driveshaft and exhaust bolts and gaskets.

    Since the exhaust has to come off, I will install my new exhaust setup when done with the clutch replacement.

    I will be placing my order today or tomorrow so, thank you in advance for any help.
    Current: 2016 Audi A4 Allroad (in progress)
    Past: 2005 Audi A4 1.8T Quattro Avant / 6-speed / Ultrasport - SOLD

  10. #10
    Veteran Member Four Rings Kevin C's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 28 2015
    AZ Member #
    323385
    My Garage
    1987 Dodge Raider G54B Turbo
    Location
    Portland OR, United States

    Quote Originally Posted by eljay View Post
    What do I need for my clutch replacement including any "while I'm there" parts? It's 2005 1.8T Quattro, 6-speed, GTRS, with 174k miles and, afaik, all original components.

    1. Valeo SMFW conversion kit - 52285615
    -- contains solid flywheel, pressure plate, clutch disc, throw-out bearing, flywheel mounting bolts, clutch alignment tool)
    2. clutch pilot bearing - 056105313C
    3. clutch fork - 01X141719B
    4. clutch release arm - 012141751C
    5. clutch release spring - 012141741
    6. ball stud - 012141777D
    7. rear main seal - 06A103171A
    8. transmission mount - 8E0399105HQ (can I just replace the rubber part? ECS seems to list both under the same part #: full and rubber-only)
    9. transmission fluid

    I got items 3-6 from old guy's recommendation in this thread.

    Anything to add to this? Any bolts to replace on the parts that will be removed?
    I found this clutch installation kit on ECS: https://www.ecstuning.com/Audi-B6_A4...Kit/ES2589667/
    Should I grab all of those components? It seems that besides my list above, it contains driveshaft and exhaust bolts and gaskets.

    Since the exhaust has to come off, I will install my new exhaust setup when done with the clutch replacement.

    I will be placing my order today or tomorrow so, thank you in advance for any help.
    FYI,

    Another option is you can also put in a stock dual mass from a B7 2.0T. You need the block spacer and starter motor from a 2.0T six speed and there is a boss on the 1.8T's block that needs to be trimmed back so that the starter motors solenoid clears. That gets you a dual mass, sprung hub disc self adjusting pressure plate and a 240mm disk.

    That was my choice based on a personal preference to keep the dual mass flywheel but get something a little better than stock . My theory is with the taller gearing of the six speed it would allow me to use sixth more often on the highway. Since I never had a single mass to compare it to, no clue if it helps. My previous clutch was a dual mass with a non sprung hub (stock 1.8T). The dual mass with the sprung hub is definitely smoother at low RPM's. The improvement was also noticeable when driving in slow traffic and school zones when your a bit fast for first and a little slow for second. Or fast for second and slow for third..... You get the idea.
    2003 02X Six speed swapped, RS4 RSB, H&R FSB, B7 brakes, 2.0T stroker, DSMIC's, B7 CTS K04 turbo.

  11. #11
    Senior Member Two Rings
    Join Date
    Apr 03 2016
    AZ Member #
    371241
    Location
    Up North

    Don't put a stock fork in there if you are doing a clutch. Those things are ticking time bombs. My Jetta had the same symptoms as your car and it was because the fork pretzeled itself. I reinforced a replacement stock one by TIG welding a plate on most of the open side. Nothing like having to pull your trans at half life on a clutch to replace a crappy $30 part...

  12. #12
    Active Member Four Rings EuroxS4's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 24 2010
    AZ Member #
    53856
    My Garage
    2003 Atlas Grey A4 Avant 1.8T 6speed manual quattro,2002 GSXR 600
    Location
    Paramus,NJ USA

    Quote Originally Posted by eljay View Post
    I believe my clutch is gone, but I would like to confirm.

    Someone else was driving my car while I was a passenger just now.
    All the sudden she couldn't shift into 3rd and clutch pedal is extremely light. We pulled over.

    With car off I couldn't shift into any gear. I tried it with starting the car and same: cannot shift into any gear. Turned off engine.
    While I was looking for a towing company number, all the sudden I could shift into gears with some difficulty, but it worked. So, I started the engine with clutch pedal pressed down. The car jumped forward. I shut off the engine. I realized that gear was engaged even when the clutch pedal was pressed down.

    Since we were only a mile from my house I realized that I could just bump the car in first and get home.
    So, with first gear engaged, I started the car and gave it a bit of gas and we managed to limp home in first. Clutch pedal didn't work, so after pulling into the driveway, I just had to hit the brake and stall the car to stop it.

    Could you guys tell me what those symptoms mean?
    My clutch was on its way out (high engagement point and light pedal action). So, is this only clutch gone or do I need to replace something else? The tranny should be OK, correct? How about the clutch slave?
    Anything else?

    I'll be ordering the Valeo SMFW conversion kit asap.

    Thank you!
    I will reply with this:She and a gtrs kit dont mix.Clutch is definitely smoked for sure.If the car is your pride and joy dont let anyone else drive it.Its like passing your girlfriend around for your friends to bang.Not something anyone in their right state of mind would want to do.Stock clutches dont like any heat at all.Perhaps she wasnt coming off the clutch all the way???Sound to me like the disk has probably separated or delaminated from heat.
    VW/Audi Immobilizer removal and immobilizer adapting solutions for any and all VAG Vehicles, Odometer matching, SKC/Pin retrieval services/ Component Protection/Module Coding/Diagnosis Services and repairs.RB4/RB8 Specialist cloning and repairs. Located in Northern NJ. For inquries pm for details or contact me via Whatsapp
    Ziddy Autowerks

  13. #13
    Veteran Member Four Rings Seerlah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 05 2007
    AZ Member #
    23104
    Location
    A place between here and there

    Upgrade to a more beefier clutch, replace pilot bearing, replace throw out bearing, inspect old clutch setup when you take it out to confirm what really happened (it will be quite obvious once taken out), be sure to look over twice the area of damage old clutch would have effected on the transmission and/or components, make sure clutch fork is not bent (hard to do without a non bent one in front of you to compare), swap in new clutch, don't EVER let a girl drive your car again (well, not someone who isn't into cars herself. that and one who is simply a really good driver. my sister is one and would have babied my FX400 clutch. only girl to have driven my car), and don't EVER let a girl drive your car again.
    I hate it when my car acts like a little bitch, treating me like a bitch

  14. #14
    Veteran Member Four Rings Spike00513's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 05 2013
    AZ Member #
    110766
    Location
    CA

    Quote Originally Posted by eljay View Post
    What do I need for my clutch replacement including any "while I'm there" parts? It's 2005 1.8T Quattro, 6-speed, GTRS, with 174k miles and, afaik, all original components.

    1. Valeo SMFW conversion kit - 52285615
    -- contains solid flywheel, pressure plate, clutch disc, throw-out bearing, flywheel mounting bolts, clutch alignment tool)
    2. clutch pilot bearing - 056105313C
    3. clutch fork - 01X141719B
    4. clutch release arm - 012141751C
    5. clutch release spring - 012141741
    6. ball stud - 012141777D
    7. rear main seal - 06A103171A
    8. transmission mount - 8E0399105HQ (can I just replace the rubber part? ECS seems to list both under the same part #: full and rubber-only)
    9. transmission fluid

    I got items 3-6 from old guy's recommendation in this thread.

    Anything to add to this? Any bolts to replace on the parts that will be removed?
    I found this clutch installation kit on ECS: https://www.ecstuning.com/Audi-B6_A4...Kit/ES2589667/
    Should I grab all of those components? It seems that besides my list above, it contains driveshaft and exhaust bolts and gaskets.

    Since the exhaust has to come off, I will install my new exhaust setup when done with the clutch replacement.

    I will be placing my order today or tomorrow so, thank you in advance for any help.
    On my 3L, I did RMS replacement at the same time. I think I found the seal alone for ~$8-$13 on AutoHausAZ or something, with a PN I found on an online interactive Corteco catalog or something. One of those seal makers. You know, Reinz, Elring, etc.
    I took my time to get it right, and I assume it is, since no leaks.
    But diagnosticator says those should last an engine lifetime, and shouldn't leak if the PCV system is in proper working order applying crank vacuum rather than pressure.

    I don't think I changed the tube that the TOB slides on. I heard you only should if it's in bad shape and scored. And there may be a trans input shaft that mounts to the back of that.
    It seems generally ETKA specs a particular blue grease for radial shaft seals, I forget PN, if you do that. Such as selector shaft seal. There was a DIY somewhere.
    Maybe other grease works? IDK. At least not petroleum-based tub of Disc Wheel Bearing Grease from AutoZone, because that eats through/dissolves. Whereas my NAPA Sil-Glyde (silicone-based) doesn't, so I've used it on stuff like caliper pin boots.

    I think ECS might be misreading manual instructions. "Replace" does not mean "buy new driveshaft bolts". It means "don't forget to put them back in place where they were". It probably also says "replace wheel", which no, does not mean you need a new $10,000 wheel every tire change like a Bugatti Veyron.

    However, my word too, is to be taken with a grain of salt. Guess all I can say is to use your best judgement and hope for the best.
    For example, I got new propshaft gaskets. I think I skipped re-greasing their joints. But otherwise, I re-used the bolts. But my Craftsman bit fit well and didn't do much damage. If I put a loose HFT bit, it would probably strip the head, and I'd NEED new bolts, without a choice. I probably took extra prep measures to loosen it too though, since I knew it's high-torque. ie heating it, putting cold water in the allen hole with eye dropper, etc.

    I didn't replace the ball stud that the fork rides on, but the manual asks to put a specific grease. I think I used whatever little packet came with the kit, clutch spline grease.
    And, for 3L RMS, the metal case it mounts into needs to be re-sealed onto the back of the engine too, with an anaerobic sealant. I only used HondaBond HT because it's what I had.
    IDK if replacing that's even necessary.

    I think I saw also a "repair kit" with plastic shifter ball on the gearbox, dunno if that's worth it.

    On 3L DP's, I ran into issue installing new hex nuts that didn't match the originals that came off. TBH I probably could've just re-used those.
    And they ruined the stud thread.

    I wanted to clean things too but I didn't. walky said you can check if trans input shaft seal leaks by standing gearbox upright. At that point, some people degrease, wash, clean, paint, etc.
    Dunno if 3M Roloc, Nyalox, wire brush, etc. has a place in that.
    I only wiped the bellhousing inside a bit with paper towels.

    Motor mounts?
    Trans mount maybe.
    Manual says damage is caused if the DP flex joint is bent past 30°

    My AST6300 doesn't strip half-shaft bolts either.
    I hear the gearbox output flanges (x2 sides, x1 rear) have seals that can leak. Mine aren't, and I ignored that area.

    Gear oil, I know people have used Motul Gear 300, and it seems good when hot. But otherwise I like Fuchs Titan SintoFluid SAE 75w80 as per Scotty@AA. Their site says it corresponds to a general OE PN that spans 01A, 01E, and B7. I don't think I found B6 02X on their catalog which makes no sense since B7 is also 02X, but a different code (GVE, vs. GJW/GJV) to show different gear ratios.

    If you're disconnecting propshaft, maybe something to clean off the old red loc-tite from the bolts, and of course new red loc-tite.
    You could rebuild the halfshafts, but that can also be done at a later date separately, if you wanna service them. Or don't, let them break, and install Raxles or something, which is OEM.

    A solvent such as brake-cleaner to clean the flywheel mating surface/face? I believe FW's and brake discs get coated with some oil to keep the fresh bare metal from rusting while it sits on a warehouse shelf waiting for you to buy it.

    Quote Originally Posted by Kevin C View Post
    FYI,

    Another option is you can also put in a stock dual mass from a B7 2.0T. You need the block spacer and starter motor from a 2.0T six speed and there is a boss on the 1.8T's block that needs to be trimmed back so that the starter motors solenoid clears. That gets you a dual mass, sprung hub disc self adjusting pressure plate and a 240mm disk.

    That was my choice based on a personal preference to keep the dual mass flywheel but get something a little better than stock . My theory is with the taller gearing of the six speed it would allow me to use sixth more often on the highway. Since I never had a single mass to compare it to, no clue if it helps. My previous clutch was a dual mass with a non sprung hub (stock 1.8T). The dual mass with the sprung hub is definitely smoother at low RPM's. The improvement was also noticeable when driving in slow traffic and school zones when your a bit fast for first and a little slow for second. Or fast for second and slow for third..... You get the idea.

    I forgot about this...
    Was it DMF049 LuK from RockAuto? I think the whole kit is $400. That's what 3L 02X uses. IDK about early 01E, maybe the same thing.
    Well, I think every Audi after used that, V6, V8, 2.0T, etc. 240mm, as posted earlier in another thread, but BFI says upcoming A4 MT will revert to 228.

    What do you mean "taller, 6th, highway". Is that because with a low power engine, having more weight on the FW is momentum to make it easier? Or are you at a speed where it acts like overdrive at low RPM for efficiency, but you wanted to make sure it feels good there too, without running into smoothness issue?

    Interesting...So is 240mm DMF > 228mm DMF?
    IDK what mine is doing. Gear lash teeth rattle? Or if I need to add euro TDI bellypan sound insulation? Because it's noisy.
    I have the Valeo kit and drove it back-to-back with DMF's. Yet Charles says he loves it. IDK how. Was mine installed wrong? There's not much that can go wrong. A disc slides onto a splined shaft. That's it. I mean yeah, you have to align it in a way that it's smooth, but that comes in the instructions. Ikea furniture a 5yr old could handle.

    And yeah, sometimes it's school-zones. Or speed bumps. Shopping centers. Traffic. Or the car isn't fully warmed up yet so you're taking it easy.
    Mine seems to put out some bass resonance falling below 2.4k rpm, such as off-throttle engine braking. Almost like a train passing next to you.
    It's not a gutted track car with a big wing. You can hear it from outside too.
    Basically it's fine 2.5k-5k but not below.
    And I hear stock 1.8T has no Fluidampr, and is an unbalanced crank without counterweights. Not a smooth V6 or V8.
    So I asked OG who has the same kit and apparently his doesn't do this.

    Well, 240mm is big and heavy. I guess Audi saw the 3L has having enough power to be fine with it still. 220chp/tq.
    Not sure how stock slower 1.8T fares. Or if it needs mods such as tune, etc.
    I mean, how much faster does SMF spin up, .1sec? Is it worth it?
    Pedal bite seems much lower.


    Especially parking. I saw a UK driver training video (most cars are stick there) which said blip throttle first.
    On my 3L DMF 240mm, I could just let out the clutch to bite and it'd move. Dunno if this wears the FW dampening.
    But now, to try and keep the car from shaking itself apart, I'll give some RPM gas FIRST then try to modulate the clutch, trying to slip as little as possible to preserve it.
    In other words, instead of fighting contact shock with a dampener, the FW is now solid so I fight it with slippage, to make it smooth and prevent stalling.

    Quote Originally Posted by Human Garbage View Post
    Don't put a stock fork in there if you are doing a clutch. Those things are ticking time bombs. My Jetta had the same symptoms as your car and it was because the fork pretzeled itself. I reinforced a replacement stock one by TIG welding a plate on most of the open side. Nothing like having to pull your trans at half life on a clutch to replace a crappy $30 part...
    Isn't that more of a thing on MKIV Jetta?
    The fork seems pretty strong. But I think OG's bent before. Are you saying get aftermarket or weld/reinforce it? Or install new OE and discard original?

    Quote Originally Posted by Seerlah View Post
    Upgrade to a more beefier clutch, replace pilot bearing, replace throw out bearing, inspect old clutch setup when you take it out to confirm what really happened (it will be quite obvious once taken out), be sure to look over twice the area of damage old clutch would have effected on the transmission and/or components, make sure clutch fork is not bent (hard to do without a non bent one in front of you to compare), swap in new clutch, don't EVER let a girl drive your car again (well, not someone who isn't into cars herself. that and one who is simply a really good driver. my sister is one and would have babied my FX400 clutch. only girl to have driven my car), and don't EVER let a girl drive your car again.
    Is it that harmful? It takes time for the foot to adapt to a new clutch especially if you're rushing it. Or if the slave could use another bleed?
    Point is, I've had people drive my car. I get back in, clutch feels different. IDK if it's slightly glazed or what.
    But it always goes back to normal with miles of me driving. I hear the material is supposed to be "self-regenerating". The OE LuK or Sachs part at least.
    Not to say that's reason enough to do it.

    ______________
    TL;DR - my reply in GIF-form:

  15. #15
    Veteran Member Four Rings Seerlah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 05 2007
    AZ Member #
    23104
    Location
    A place between here and there

    ^Learned my lesson at maybe 17. Let girl I knew since the 3rd grade (linked back up with her years later couple times in my life, and bet it will happen again. last was when I bumped into her my last b-day) drive my old Honda from street to back of the apt building we are hanging out at. Figured no harm, automatic, what harm can she really do going a few yards away. Felt so confident, I gave her my keys and didn't even sit passenger seat. She hit a stockade or solid board fencing as she made the turn into the back of the building. So to reiterate...



    But to give her(one in OP that damaged clutch) benefit of the doubt, our clutch engagement points do ride incredibly high. She probably thought no harm and did on the A4 what can be done on other vehicles. Or maybe I'm just looking at it incorrectly and she should have had her foot completely off clutch to begin with, as someone else previously mentioned (ie foot off clutch if not using the clutch).
    I hate it when my car acts like a little bitch, treating me like a bitch

  16. #16
    Veteran Member Four Rings eljay's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 13 2015
    AZ Member #
    348695
    Location
    NS

    So, to settle the girl driving my car debate, so we can get back to my list of parts.... ;)
    Let me just add that my wife drives this car daily for the past year. She loves manual, knows how to drive one to the point that the only thing she's missing from her skills is heel-toe, which I do all the time BTW. So, between the two of us, we are very easy on the clutch. I've never sidestepped a clutch on any of my cars and don't do any dragstrip-like driving.
    A shop I trust told me the clutch is worn last year; about 8k ago.
    The car has 174k and the last 55k of those were with GTRS kit. All on original clutch. So, I would say that's a pretty good record.
    Now, the girl that drove the car is my sister in law. She took off in first and my wife encouraged her to get on it, which she did in first, shifting around 6k. Then she shifted into second and took it easy since we were in the city and when she went for third and couldn't shift into it. At this point she still could get back into 2nd and accelerate onto the highway, but not being able to shift into 3rd again, we pulled over. Clutch done.

    Reading more about the symptoms, it does feel like the clutch fork is gone and not allowing the disengagement.
    Now, I don't see many early clutch fork failures to warrant spending 10x the price on a reinforced one.
    If a new OEM or Luk, Sachs fork lasts another 174k, that's a very good record and nothing to complain about in terms of OEM durability.

    Regarding my parts, I'll go study the repair procedure to see if I need to add any TTY bolts.
    Current: 2016 Audi A4 Allroad (in progress)
    Past: 2005 Audi A4 1.8T Quattro Avant / 6-speed / Ultrasport - SOLD

  17. #17
    Veteran Member Four Rings Seerlah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 05 2007
    AZ Member #
    23104
    Location
    A place between here and there

    You don't need a reinforced fork. But some pressure plates place more strain onto the fork the the slave cylinder rod sits in. With the more popular clutch brands, South Bend is the only one documented I have seen do this. If you can, possibly pick up a cheap used one on ebay to use for comparison just to check if the fork is bent, when replacing the clutch. And if it is, swap it out.

    Best thing to do is not jump to conclusions, but just prepare to get the thing fixed. Not that big of a deal. Standard clutch change with the added extra fork, in case current one if bent. But I don't think that is the case. I personally thing she created so much heat then other components got too hot (slightly slipping all the way to 6k rpm can do that). But these are all guesses right now with same conclusion. Get clutch replaced. My post was quite easy and to the point. But now, having a replacement fork handy should be added to the list also.

    Valeo SMFW is not sufficient for the GTRS. Choose a proper torque rated clutch setup.
    I hate it when my car acts like a little bitch, treating me like a bitch

  18. #18
    Veteran Member Four Rings Spike00513's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 05 2013
    AZ Member #
    110766
    Location
    CA

    Quote Originally Posted by eljay View Post
    Let me just add that my wife drives this car daily for the past year. She loves manual, knows how to drive one to the point that the only thing she's missing from her skills is heel-toe, which I do all the time BTW. So, between the two of us, we are very easy on the clutch.
    How does one achieve this...
    Also, I thought the pedals aren't set up for heel-toe?
    What about left-foot braking. Don't rally drivers do that while adding a bit of throttle to keep the turbo ready, since brakes easily overcome the engine?
    On some cars though, the stock electronics don't let you. For example if you're cruising, light throttle, and tap the brake pedal just enough to flash the light, the fuel cuts. I think.

    Quote Originally Posted by eljay View Post
    A shop I trust told me the clutch is worn last year; about 8k ago.
    The car has 174k and the last 55k of those were with GTRS kit. All on original clutch. So, I would say that's a pretty good record.
    Now, the girl that drove the car is my sister in law. She took off in first and my wife encouraged her to get on it, which she did in first, shifting around 6k. Then she shifted into second and took it easy since we were in the city and when she went for third and couldn't shift into it. At this point she still could get back into 2nd and accelerate onto the highway, but not being able to shift into 3rd again, we pulled over. Clutch done.

    Reading more about the symptoms, it does feel like the clutch fork is gone and not allowing the disengagement.
    Now, I don't see many early clutch fork failures to warrant spending 10x the price on a reinforced one.
    If a new OEM or Luk, Sachs fork lasts another 174k, that's a very good record and nothing to complain about in terms of OEM durability.

    Regarding my parts, I'll go study the repair procedure to see if I need to add any TTY bolts.
    Wonder if the fork and pressure plate fingers are hurt by sitting for a while with the clutch held in, which I assume nobody does. Just go into neutral at a stoplight.
    But even short engagements add up over time

  19. #19
    Veteran Member Four Rings Kevin C's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 28 2015
    AZ Member #
    323385
    My Garage
    1987 Dodge Raider G54B Turbo
    Location
    Portland OR, United States

    Quote Originally Posted by Spike00513 View Post

    What do you mean "taller, 6th, highway". Is that because with a low power engine, having more weight on the FW is momentum to make it easier? Or are you at a speed where it acts like overdrive at low RPM for efficiency, but you wanted to make sure it feels good there too, without running into smoothness issue?
    Taller gear (final drive ratio): The six speed reduces the engines RPM on the highway (compared to the five speed it replaced). To get the greatest benefit of the taller final drive, I decided to stay with a dual mass flywheel. That allows me to be in sixth at 60 or so MPH. Research has shown that a dual mass will provide about 5% better fuel economy, feels smoother and it reduces stress on the transmission. My HP plans are pretty modest so I did not see a need to go to a single mass.

    http://fmpmotorfactors.com/wp-conten...r-a-reason.pdf
    2003 02X Six speed swapped, RS4 RSB, H&R FSB, B7 brakes, 2.0T stroker, DSMIC's, B7 CTS K04 turbo.

  20. #20
    Veteran Member Four Rings eljay's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 13 2015
    AZ Member #
    348695
    Location
    NS

    Quote Originally Posted by Kevin C View Post
    Taller gear (final drive ratio): The six speed reduces the engines RPM on the highway (compared to the five speed it replaced). To get the greatest benefit of the taller final drive, I decided to stay with a dual mass flywheel. That allows me to be in sixth at 60 or so MPH. Research has shown that a dual mass will provide about 5% better fuel economy, feels smoother and it reduces stress on the transmission. My HP plans are pretty modest so I did not see a need to go to a single mass.

    http://fmpmotorfactors.com/wp-conten...r-a-reason.pdf
    No doubt, the DMF has advantages. For me, the lower cost and still good usability were factors in my decision to go with the Valeo SMFW kit, which has been well reviewed. Again, the 174k miles with 55k of those with GTRS are a testament to OEM DMF durability.
    Current: 2016 Audi A4 Allroad (in progress)
    Past: 2005 Audi A4 1.8T Quattro Avant / 6-speed / Ultrasport - SOLD

  21. #21
    Veteran Member Four Rings eljay's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 13 2015
    AZ Member #
    348695
    Location
    NS

    Quote Originally Posted by Spike00513 View Post
    How does one achieve this...
    Also, I thought the pedals aren't set up for heel-toe?
    What about left-foot braking. Don't rally drivers do that while adding a bit of throttle to keep the turbo ready, since brakes easily overcome the engine?
    On some cars though, the stock electronics don't let you. For example if you're cruising, light throttle, and tap the brake pedal just enough to flash the light, the fuel cuts. I think.
    How does one achieve a wife who refuses to drive automatics or the heel-toe part?

    I actually find the B6 quite nice for heel-toe in terms of pedal arrangement. Much better than my MK4 Golf was, for example, but even on that one, I could do heel-toe comfortably. Of course, there are better pedal arrangements for that and engine characteristics play a role too (e.g. in my experience, you need to stab the throttle a tad more with turbo cars to bring the revs up sufficiently compared to better responding NA drivetrains).

    Start with blipping throttle on dowshifts without braking. Once you master that, start practicing light braking and rolling your foot over to blip the throttle. The reason for trying with light braking first is that you don't end up slowing down too much requiring more brake and throttle pedal movement.

    Regarding the fuel cut on brake application, that happens more in the left-foot braking scenario where clutch is fully engaged and certain brake force applied. I've never had that issue with heel-toe while the clutch pedal is in.

    Wonder if the fork and pressure plate fingers are hurt by sitting for a while with the clutch held in, which I assume nobody does. Just go into neutral at a stoplight.
    But even short engagements add up over time
    Possibly. I'll see what the failure was upon replacement. I ordered fork and associated pieces to be ready. It does feel like the fork or the release bearing went.
    Current: 2016 Audi A4 Allroad (in progress)
    Past: 2005 Audi A4 1.8T Quattro Avant / 6-speed / Ultrasport - SOLD

  22. #22
    Veteran Member Four Rings Charles.waite's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 27 2011
    AZ Member #
    77478
    Location
    Seattle, WA

    Rev matching downshifts is relatively easy, definitely easier with a light flywheel (or a fast revving NA engine). Learning to heel toe just doesn't seem worth the effort on a street car. Seems like it would introduce more wear and tear as well.

    Either way There's no such thing as a "reinforced clutch fork" for our cars so even if it was worthwhile, the product simply isn't available.

    Depending on the OP's time/cost math, I would overbuy in the parts area up front in order to minimize downtime and minimize unexpected issues.
    -CP
    2008 2.0t S-Line Ti 6MT Avant
    2017 Q7 3.0t
    SOLD -- 2012 Q5 2.0t - Stock Mommy Missile with new timing chains
    Former USP CLUB MEMBER #136
    2004 A4 1.8TQ 6MT USP - APR Stage 1+ - FSI Coils - BKR7EIX-11 - B6S4 Front + B7A4 Rear Brakes - 034 Street Trans Mount
    SOLD -- 2006 A4 2.0TQ Avant Tiptronic

  23. #23
    Senior Member Two Rings
    Join Date
    Apr 03 2016
    AZ Member #
    371241
    Location
    Up North

    Quote Originally Posted by eljay View Post
    ...Regarding the fuel cut on brake application, that happens more in the left-foot braking scenario where clutch is fully engaged and certain brake force applied...
    Two variables in ME7.5 determine throttle lockout: NWPMBBR (Minimum RPM for acc pedal value lockout on brake operation) and VWPMBBR (Minimum speed for acc pedal value lockout on brake operation). I don't have the stock values at hand (my tuning laptop is in my trunk) but they are pretty low (like 1600 RPM and 3 km/h respectively). I change them to 6800 RPM and 256 km/h to defeat the lockout.

    Quote Originally Posted by Charles.waite View Post
    Rev matching downshifts is relatively easy, definitely easier with a light flywheel (or a fast revving NA engine). Learning to heel toe just doesn't seem worth the effort on a street car. Seems like it would introduce more wear and tear as well.

    Either way There's no such thing as a "reinforced clutch fork" for our cars so even if it was worthwhile, the product simply isn't available.
    I've been heel and toeing since I learned to drive. My Dad taught me how to double clutch so I could drive the real old iron without syncros. Double clutching is made really easy and fast by heel and toeing. I still do it to be nice to my transmissions, especially when it is cold. I won't dispute it might not be of a benefit to learn for some people however. I'm hard wired after almost 30 years of doing it, so I can't be objective on that front.

    As far as the reinforced clutch fork is concerned, this is what ECS states on their fork web page: "If your having trouble with clutch engagement or release, the clutch fork should be your first suspect." Having worked in a parts department, I can say that those who sell parts know what breaks most often! So I will beg to differ on the benefit of a reinforced fork based on my experience (and apparently that of ECS too).

    While there may not be a commercial source for them readily available, anyone with a welder can make one quick (perhaps that explains the lack of retailers). If I wasn't 900km from my TIG right now I would make one for the OP. Any welder worth the title could whip one up out of a stock unit in minutes. I didn't even finish a beer in the time it took me.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  


    © 2001-2025 Audizine, Audizine.com, and Driverzines.com
    Audizine is an independently owned and operated automotive enthusiast community and news website.
    Audi and the Audi logo(s) are copyright/trademark Audi AG. Audizine is not endorsed by or affiliated with Audi AG.