Originally Posted by
kobrian85
Jason, wondering if you could help me (and possibly others) understand why the 8mm spacer has slop in the wheel itself as Acejam pointed out in his video, and how the 10mm spacer does not? I think I follow your response that the lip on the 8mm spacer is smaller because the "system" utilizes a portion of the factory hub extension and thus the lip on the 8mm spacer is more shallow? And is this inherently a potential problem with 8mm spacers, regardless of the manufacturer, since Acejam is comparing only ECS products?
That's like putting an 8mm bolt into a non-threaded hole that's made for a 10mm bolt. Sure, it'll "fit" and be snug "in and out" of the hole since there is a nut on the other end to help keep it tight. However, the hole is bored for 10mm, and so it's possible for the bolt to move side to side. If that bolt isn't exactly 100% centered perfectly, you're going to get wheel vibrations.
Sorry, but I call that not fitting.
Originally Posted by
ECS Tuning-Audi
Like I mentioned it could have been that the tolerance on the spacers he received was out of spec. Which would deem them defective, which we would gladly accept them back if he sent them in and we ran them against our figures and they proved to be out.
The lip is smaller because there is simply not enough material on an 8mm to create an "extension" like that of the 10mm. You have to remember the factory hub has to fit inside of this spacer and it's just thick enough that it doesn't even poke through. You would need more material to machine and extension like on a 10mm spacer. 8mm only allows you to add a wheel centric lip.
Jason
8mm only allows you enough material to create a HUB centric lip. There isn't enough material on the spacer to protrude into the wheel hub far enough for stabilization, so it's most certainly NOT wheel-centric.
The optimal spacer, like your 10mm one, is both HUB and WHEEL centric. The 8mm ones are only hub centric. They have a "wheel centric looking" lip, but it's not long enough, and that is exactly what's causing the problem.
The extra material on the factory rotor hub and 10mm spacer allows for the wheel to center and stabilize. Without this, you get vibrations. This is critical! Why is ECS selling a product that removes this stabilization and claims that it is OK?
I've also tested other ECS "v2" 8mm spacers and they also have the exact same problem. There is no defect here, they just don't fit, plain and simple.
Originally Posted by
kobrian85
Thanks for the explanation! Then in theory, there shouldn't be that slop, that Acejam is able to show in his video, when you put the 8mm spacer behind the week? And if there is, we should assume that was a defective spacer? Is it possible that there could be similar slop also based on the wheel that maybe has a "bust" in its spec as well?
The spacer is not defective, it will always vibrate unless you get lucky and manage to center it perfectly. Why bother struggling with having to center it? Just get a proper fitting spacer that does what the factory gives you - a stable smooth ride and a centered wheel 100% of the time.
Bookmarks