Just wanted to add to this thread - thanks to the helpful comments on here, I was able to replace my broken fan at a minimal cost (about $130 for a German-made Behr-Hella fan, part #351044351) and in just a few hours. Here's a few notes from my experience:
1) By replacing just the broken fan itself instead of the entire shroud, I did NOT have to remove the front bumper or the fan shroud, nor did I have to disconnect any radiator hoses (except for the small line running from the coolant reservoir), all of which probs saved a ton of time.
2) I removed the upper and lower black plastic trim pieces protecting (or blocking access to) the radiator area, then removed the two vertical trim pieces that sit directly on either side of the radiator and run from the top to the bottom of the engine bay to shield the radiator from debris. These vertical pieces were difficult to remove without breaking - take your time with them. I couldn't get them out without breaking at least one or two tabs or each one, but that was fine.
3) After removing the stuff in the way, I was able to loosen the radiator enough to move it forward about 3 inches. I had a helper, and at that point we tried to get the entire fan shroud out, but it was heckin' impossible. High fives to the other dudes on this thread that got the entire shroud out without removing the radiator, but we spent almost two hours trying and the clearances were just too tight. That's when I just moved on to replacing the fan by itself. (As a side note, I can confirm that the diagrams above are correct, and that you only need to loosen the tabs at the "5 and 6" positions described above to remove the shroud.)
4) With the 3 inches of play in the radiator position, I was able to pull the rad forward, reach down, and remove the three screws that attached the fan motor to the shroud. Then I simply slid the old fan out the top ( I had to remove the hood latch assembly from the rad support first), and with some wriggling I was able to slide the new fan down back into position.
Screwing the new fan into the shroud also took some patience, but that was essentially it - take off all the stuff in the way, loosen the shroud from the radiator, loosen the radiator so it has about 3 inches of forward movement, unattach the broken fan from the shroud, slide it out the top, slide the new fan in, screw it into position, plug the electrical conection back in, reposition the shroud properly, put it all back together, and if you have no leftover screws then it's beer time. Cheers.
Bookmarks