Just looking for some opinions on insurance companies, whether I should switch or not. Currently I'm with Geico for about 5 or so years but I'm in the process of leasing a Tiguan and decided to get quotes from other companies. Here's how it's looking:

Geico - 1116 for 6 months
Allstate - 906 for 6 months
Progressive - 909 for 6 months

The same coverage with all 3 with the exception of no uninsured property damage with Allstate because for some reason it won't allow me to add it to the quote because 2 cars only have comprehensive and the third has full coverage.

I haven't had any issues with Geico but I also haven't had to file any claims with them. I'll be saving $200 or so by switching but is it worth it? Do the other companies have good, reliable customer service? Will they give me a hard time in the event of an accident?