Originally Posted by
kwilson
I had this exact issue with my son's A4. I think we ended up harvesting the plastic top off of a new lower tube. Issue is that the upper does not grip the bottom well anymore. I've tried several upper tubes (including Genuine parts) and it tends to pull off when checking oil if you don't hold it down with something while pulling the dipstick.
I think I remember that the tip came off really easy of the new lower.
Ok, so status update on my previous plan. I bought the slide hammer with pilot bearing attachment, and no matter how hard I tried, that lower dipstick tube would not extract from the block. The attachment would pull out of the tube every time. I probably hammered on it dozens of times each attempt, and the tube never even pulled out of the block by a fingernail's thickness. Those things are in there for keeps. I tried wrenching it back and forth but the metal started fatiguing and it felt like it was going to snap off at that base. I recommend against trying that.
I ended up going with the backup plan, using the plastic end of a new tube I bought off Amazon($15) that KW and I mentioned up above. Once you pull the plastic end off the new tube, you'll notice it was barely glued on as some dried glue will flake out of the end. You may want to re-glue it to the old pipe once you put it back on, although I didn't as my situation was different. Because I had used the pilot bearing puller on the tube, it had the effect of flaring the tube out about 1-2mm so it took a bit of force to put the plastic piece back on. I felt like once it was done though, it was secured better than even the glue had held it. I found that a 19mm 12point deep socket would hold the plastic piece perfectly, and with a 1 foot extension on a 3/8 drive breaker bar I was able to position the plastic piece onto the oil tube and hammer it on till it bottomed out. Then I put the new oil funnel (orange tube) back on the top of it and it snapped on firmly.
Bookmarks