Here's my take on the valve body troubleshooting: Always swap in a DIFFERENT valve body. Even if it's a used one that you don't know anything about.
If you have it back together, valve body drained/ cleaned etc..and it does EXACTLY the same thing what have you learned? You still don't know for sure if the valve body has a bad solenoid or what. Unless you're a guru and can decipher MBV of the trans module with Vag Com then it's pretty hard to narrow it down by cleaning that valve body.
Others might disagree; but I don't think these transmission problems we typically see are very often valve body related, in fact it's kind of pretty rare. So if you had swapped the VB with any other one and it did exactly the same thing I'd feel okay with a bad trans diagnosis; so you have learned something. IF on the other hand it behaves VERY different then you've learned something that way also. This is because the odds of two VB's having a similar or identical failure is not likely.
By reinstalling the old VB the only way you know anything new is IF it is fixed. If it's NOT fixed...then ...? you still don't know if part of the VB is bad.
Either way...good luck.
Bookmarks