Long time lurker, sometime contributor here. Thanks in advance to all those that post I have learned a lot on the forum over the past few years. Some love to research which I am one, and I know guys get beat up a bit for asking the notorious Stage 1, 2 questions, is it worth it TD1 blah, blah. Figured I would add my impressions as no one beats you up for writing a review and contributing.
History: Bought new 2013 S4, 6MT, Monsoon Grey (blacked out trim), loaded without Audi Drive Select, however did get the Sports Diff (Def'ly a must, IMHO)
I was conscious about warranty as my APR dealer is 4.5 hours away so switching back an fourth was not an option. I started with RS4 Grille, Eurocode Sway bars, end links, Alu Kreuz Billet Aluminum Drivetrain Stabilizer, and Eurocode TRUFit Air Intake. I found the suspension upgrades a great improvement over stock. I found it tightened up the suspension, no more dipping the front of the car in high speed tight turns and the car felt far more agile overall. I like the intake, not super loud but you can hear it when you are on the throttle, it is a good mid range for sound and does what I need it to do at a reasonable price.
I found I was prepping my car as I knew I wanted to go to Stage 2 (personally don't know why one would go stage 1 only) It is a small amount to pay for the upgrade. The way I look at the price of a tune is; if it were available when ordering from the factory, would you check the checkbox for the extra 100hp and increase in torque for a little over $2k? Hell yes!
I waited and got my 55,000 km service a bit early and headed off to my APR dealer and had my stage 2 installed at the same time as my Transmission mount.
I have to say I always felt on my 6MT letting out the clutch there was always an bit of a jolt from my transmission physically moving. I assumed maybe it was bad shifting technique, but I have to say the transmission mount took that right away for $45.00 it is a great upgrade to feeling much smoother shifts in the 6MT.
Now Stage II - I knew I wanted it but had warranty concerns etc. After almost 3 years of having the car I know the car well, I know it's limitations, I can feel the top end of what it is capable of etc. I am far enough into my warranty that I am less likely to have any major issues. I read many reviews of some saying Stage 2 was awesome and some saying that it was marginal. I have to say for me it is a noticeable difference, well worth the cost of the upgrade.
The car was immediately more responsive, I found the torque did kick in a bit earlier, not significantly earlier, however the power band is so much smoother and more powerful. You can feel the difference in torque, and accelerating so smooth and quick now. I know the additional torque numbers are not huge (stage 1 vs 2) but combined with the higher HP I feel the car pull so much better now. You just get there so much faster. I appreciate the extension of the red line limiter, pushing further into the power band doesn't feel like it drops off. I have a 91 octane mix as I can't get 93 in Atlantic Canada. It has been a great edition. Part of me is glad I waited as I can appreciate it a bit more, I am keeping the car for some time and it is like getting an upgraded car because it is. I found it is an impressive upgrade.
Next I am putting in my P3 guage with the boost tap so I can get some 0-60 numbers as I don't have a drag strip nearby and only in the summer, I also like to see what my boost psi will be. I like to keep my car looking pretty stock
I wasn't a car real car guy before but I am very much enjoying my S4, it is a great sleeper car. You might not turn heads outside of the car but you def'ly do inside the car the first time you take someone for a drive!
Next Steps: Got recommended some KW coilovers which I will do some research as it is still a DD. I suspect a Stage 3/4 clutch may be in order and, some new brake pads and will replace exhaust down the road when needed.
Bookmarks