
Originally Posted by
mgiglio
^thread seems to talk about notchiness related to faulty steering racks. I don't think this is a rack problem, this is a software or calibration issue. I'm not talking about "notchiness" unless people mean that term for vagueness and loosing feedback. The easiest way to describe it is that on the highway and on turns the steering goes from feeling tight to very light and back to tight again within a matter of split seconds. This causes the drifting on the highway and when cornering because you're compensating for the lack of feeling for an instant and using more input than you should, then the steering gets tight again and your car steers more than it should have.
You are hitting the nail right on the head. In the original mega-thread people were talking about the steering "slipping" causing the car to drift off track, implying that there was some disparity between the motion of the steering wheel and the movement of the steering rack, as though this were a true "steer by wire" system with no positive mechanical connection between the steering wheel and the steering rack. But in reality there is a pinion engaged with the rack similar to the previous generation hydraulic assist system, only the method of providing steering assist has changed.
I agree that the "slip" people are experiencing is due to the movement of the steering wheel that happens under the force of the driver's hands as the steering assist level (i.e. the torque resisting the steering wheel's rotation) fluctuates. Here is why I think this is true: there is a stretch of straight and relatively flat road that I drive every day on my way home from work. If I have both hands on the wheel at 10:30 and 2:30 and try to keep the car moving straight ahead, the feedback from the steering wheel is that it does not want to stay centered. I can certainly position it in the center but there is very little resistance to manual input to keep it centered. There seems to be excessive assist at/near top dead center, especially when approaching it from the left. Meanwhile on the same stretch of road if I center the steering wheel and take both hands off the wheel, the steering wheel stays centered and the car tracks straight.
I recently had the car aligned and the front and rear toe are right in the middle of OEM specs. Front camber is more negative than OEM spec but I can't see how camber would affect steering/tracking. When my hands are off the wheel the steering wheel and car stay straight on flat road surfaces. So I agree this is clearly a problem of incorrect steering assist level at/near steering wheel centered position which causes the user to inadvertently overcorrect the steering wheel position based on the amount of resistance felt. But what we don't know is whether it is a software problem, a hardware problem (not the rack but maybe the electric motor?) or a combination of both...
Bookmarks