Originally Posted by
JD23
It is interesting to see this 10 year old thread revived. I remember debating Audi reliability on another site at roughly the same time with people who were convinced that Audi reliability had improved to the point of being considered as good as that of Honda. LOL. The lesson, as always, is to never buy a completely redesigned Audi and expect decent reliability.
Yep. That's part of the reason I wanted to revive it; that attitude was prevalent in the ~2008-2012 timeframe, before the reliability issues of this era of cars initially started to come to light. That, and I remember finding this thread when I googled 'B8 reliability' before purchasing my used B8. Of course, it wasn't super useful as it was super-old, and a bit of a distraction in contrast to other threads which are unfortunately not as far up in the Google results.
However, from owning a B5 A4, Mk5 GTI, B7 A4, and now a B8 A4, I think I'm spotting a trend on Audi/VAG. On one series they'll have a slew of issues, which will get the brand a bit of 'bad-name'. And then the new series will come out, which fixes all that stuff. And there'll be a talk of how much better/greater the new series is, and how 'we're finally there' on reliability. And then, the slew of new issues will start to become apparent, will become the
new well-known slew of issues. And so it starts again.
I was checking out B8.5s, because from the sounds of it on here, their much much better WRT reliability (and I don't doubt it), but in the Googling, I found this:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/money...eat/545548002/
Not as bad as the B8 issues - for sure - but I'll be interested to see as the B8.5 MYs start to get up in mileage, what/how many other things continue the cycle. And of course, some series are simply way better than others. B8 seems to be one of the worst. Late B5 probably one of the best.
And in talking to an Audi representative the other day, I asked him about design items/choices, like the air suspension on the old Allroad (which failed all the time), and the newer air suspension on the Q7 series. His response was fantastically candid: "When it comes to buying an Audi, it's really a decision of how long you want to keep the vehicle. The sweet-spot is about 4-5 year service life, as it's not a matter of if design items like that will fail but rather when they'll fail."
I didn't have any retort to him, as I appreciated his candor, as it totally re-affirmed my recent view as to how/why Audi/VAG continues to do well in spite of their reliability; those who buy new vehicles, their target market and of course how they make money, don't care about long-term reliability. They've bought a new one buy the time that stuff would matter.
And don't get me wrong, I really enjoy taking stuff apart and putting it back together, and I guess more importantly, having an excuse to do so. So I love owning VW/Audi. I've gotten to take nearly everything apart, fix it, and put it back together. It feels like a badge of pride to have a 2009 A4 running well.
The only thing I haven't done yet is complete disassemble the engine (taking everything down to individual components), which I'll be doing in a week or two on a friend's 2009 B8, to see how much damage a failed injector did to the cylinder 4 pistons/rings/cylinder. If the cylinder is OK enough we'll probably just replace all the pistons/rings/connecting rods and rebuild it.
What I'm trying to say is that there's a big upside to such lack of reliability - one gets to learn WAY more about how a car works and how to fix it. Take driving a Toyota for example: I have no idea how to do the timing work on my Highlander, or replace the brake vacuum pump, or suspension, and so on - because nothing has ever broken or even sounded weird. Which is a bummer if you like fixing stuff. :-) And or course on Audi's I know how to do all that (and have done it all, because it broke) and more, which is awesome.
As I like to say, you just have to choose what you want to buy, and why you want to buy it: If you buy Toyota, you get a reliable car. If you buy Audi, you get a reliable hobby.
I wanted a reliable car and a reliable hobby, so I bought both. :-)
Cheers!
Bookmarks