Originally Posted by
S4DTM
Hmmm...i disagree for the most part. True, in the hands of professional drivers on a closed road or track, the M3 may outperform the RS4 (ya, I've seen all the videos from Top Gear, Automobile Mag, etc.). The IS-F comes close, but even in those types of situations the RS4 tends to be pretty even with the Lexus. HOWEVER, you put all of these cars in the hands of normal drivers, and take them to the Napa or Santa Cruz backroads I guarantee the RS4 takes the cake. In fact, I'd be willing to bet that my S4 would put a pretty heavy beating on both the M3 and IS-F. We should talk performance from an everyday driver standpoint, not a professional and/or track situation IMHO. All nice cars, but still...I'd take the RS4 any day
My god... I thought Bimmer drivers had their heads stuck up their ass... What you are saying makes you look very ignorant. What you just said makes you sound like you are bitter about a car that was engineered so well that does better than your favorite car. The nose heavy, underpowered, outdated S4 will beat the new M3 on public roads with normal drivers, do you mean during a snow storm or hurricane?! You need to kill the ignorance and realize that the M3 outperforms the hell out of the RS4 in every perspective let alone the S4. I dont know what you consider a normal driver to be, and I also don't know why it makes such a difference that it's on a "closed course" or not. Obviously if you are racing against a 65 year old woman then obviously you will outperform. I am talking about two drivers with the same driving experience. Facts are facts and no matter what you do, your S4 will never outperform the E90 M3, possibly even with the supercharger. The RS4 has been beat in every test compared to the m3, and that includes acceleration, braking, skidpad, track times, and slalom. The IS-F is also on the same level and also beats the RS4... Although the RS4 is aesthetically nice and has a very nice interior, it is also a very good performing car, just not as good as the competition. Keep in mind that all of those cars cost less as well. I don't know why anyone would purchase the RS4 (if AWD is not necessary) over those cars that outperform it. the M3, C63, IS-F, and RS4 are flagship cars built for serious performance, and the main reason people buy those cars are strictly for performance reasons, if not then you can just go get a 335, c300, is350, or A4 and they pretty much do the same thing but with much less performance figures.
I'm not a hardcore audi fan, and especially with the problems Ive been encountering with my S4, I might never drive an Audi again. Maybe i've just been unlucky with this car. I appreciate all cars, and if there is something superior, then it needs to be appreciated. I am in no way in debt to Audi so Im not sure why people defend the company like it's their own. BMW, Benz, Audi, Lexus are all great companies and there are a lot of excellent cars engineered by each and every one of them, but if there is a car that is made for raw performance, like the M3, it needs to be recognized.
Bookmarks